A note about links: If we include links to retail sites like Amazon or Bass Pro Shops, it's because they're relevant to the topic and, as anglers ourselves, we believe they're worth checking out. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
What it is
A trolling reel is built for one job: dragging baits behind a moving boat for hours and putting them right back where they worked. Most are round, levelwind reels — sturdier and higher-capacity than a typical casting reel — because trolling pulls hard and steady for a long time, not in quick bursts. The reel overview covers the broader family; this is the workhorse cousin of the group.
The standout feature is the line counter — a little dial on top that ticks off the feet of line you let out. When a fish hits at 90 feet back, you reel up, drop the same lure to 90, and you are fishing the exact depth and distance that just produced. In trolling, that repeatability is everything, and it is the difference between one fish and a pattern.
When to reach for one
Reach for a trolling reel anytime you are pulling lures behind the boat rather than casting to a spot. On the Great Lakes that means walleye, salmon, and lake trout fished on downriggers, diving planers, or leadcore line — presentations where knowing your exact payout matters. Inshore in salt, the same reels handle kingfish and stripers dragged along structure and bait schools.
If you are casting, jigging, or working a spot by hand, this is more reel than you need. But the moment depth and distance become the puzzle — and in trolling they almost always are — a line-counter levelwind earns its keep.
How to choose
Start with the line counter and the levelwind. The counter gives you repeatable depth; the levelwind lays line back and forth across the spool so it pays out clean and tangle-free straight from a rod holder. Skip either feature and you lose the two things that make trolling easy.
Look for a smooth, progressive drag. At trolling speed a fish slams the bait while the boat is still moving, so the drag has to cushion that hit and absorb headshakes without popping the line — a startup that grabs hard will tear hooks loose.
For size, a reel in the 200-300 class holds plenty of 15-30 lb line or 18-30 lb braid for most freshwater and inshore work; step up to a 400-450 class for big lake trout, salmon, or leadcore setups that eat a lot of capacity. Match it to a moderate-action trolling rod — the softer tip works with the drag to keep a thrashing fish pinned.
Brands worth knowing
Okuma Cold Water Line Counter is the value entry point — a reliable counter and levelwind at a budget price ($60-90), and a great first trolling reel. Its step-up sibling, the Okuma Convector, adds a smoother drag and tougher build in the mid tier ($90-120).
Shimano Tekota is the long-running favorite for serious trolling — buttery drag, durable gearing, and a counter anglers trust season after season ($180-250, premium). Daiwa Sealine is the workhorse middle ground, rugged and dependable for walleye and salmon alike ($120-160).
For salt-leaning anglers, the Penn Fathom Line Counter brings sealed, corrosion-fighting drag and serious muscle for kingfish and stripers ($150-200), so it shrugs off spray and big inshore fish.